BAKED GOODS PROUDLY HOMEMADE FROM SCRATCH!
To Order: Please stop in or call us at 845-534-4445.
Most orders may be accommodated within 1 days notice however items marked with * require at least 2 days notice. To ensure your satisfaction we recommend placing holiday orders at least 1 week in advance!
Single Layer Carrot Cake: $15.25 (9 in. round)
Our most popular item! Deadly Carrot Cake with cream cheese icing
Double Layer Carrot Cake*: $32.50 (serves 12)
Half Sheet Carrot Cake*: $65.50 (serves up to 50)
Full sheet Carrot Cake*: $115.25 (serves up to 100)
$12.95 (9 in. round) Aunt Linda’s moist apple cake with chunks of fresh apples. Available with or without nuts.
$11.95 This home-style dessert comes in an 8 in. round pan of apples and cinnamon with a rich crumbly topping – just waiting for a scoop of vanilla ice cream! Yum!
$9.50 / lb. or $14.95 (8 in square tart) A butter almond crust with your choice of raspberry or apricot filling
$15.50 (8 in. square tart) A toasted walnut shortbread crust with filling of chocolate chips, raisins & walnuts and a hazelnut spread
Chocolate Walnut Rugelach Tart
$7.50 (7 in. loaf) Moist apricot banana bread with apricot bits and apricot glaze.
Apricot Banana Bread
$24.95 / $($27.95 w / Writing) Jumbo version of our homemade cookies with icing. Available in Chocolate Chip, Toll House Oat, Oatmeal Raisin and Snickerdoodle.
Gourmet Jumbo Cookie Cake
$7.25 (7 in. loaf) A moist pumpkin nut loaf with walnuts and cinnamon cream cheese glaze.
Pumpkin Nut Bread
$9.50 (6 in. round bundt) Annie B’s special spice cake is an old- fashioned spice cake with a dollop of spicy cream cheese frosting.
Dry coffee cake no more! Our moist coffee cake is bursting with buttery nut flavor – a great way to start the day.Plain: $13.75 (tall 8 in. round tube pan) With Chocolate Chips: $14.25 (tall 8 in. round tube pan)
Sour Cream Pecan Streusel Coffee Cake
$13.75 (9 in. round) a new twist on an old favorite! Our bread pudding features apple cider donuts in addition to the traditional butter, eggs, heavy cream and a splash of rum.
Apple Cider Donut Bread Pudding
$15.95 (7 in. round)
Traditional-A classic cheesecake with velvety texture over Graham cracker crust
Marble- A chocolate swirl cheesecake over chocolate crust
Chocolate Chip-Our traditional cheesecake with chocolate chips throughout, over a chocolate crust
$15.95 Our classic, moist pound cake bursting with boozy nuts.
$6.95 (7 in. loaf) Our moist blueberry bread filled with fresh blueberries and crumb topping.
Blueberry Crumb Tea Bread
FOR THE CHOCOLATE LOVER
Single Layer - $14.25 (9 in. round)
Dark Chocolate Mousse Cake
A rich dark chocolate cake with whipped chocolate mousse topping
Double Layer* - $34.75
$15.95 (7 in. round) A rich and creamy peanut butter mousse over a chocolate crust, smothered in chocolate Ganache
Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse Cake
Single Layer- $19.50 (9 in. round)
German Chocolate Cake*
A rich, dark chocolate cake with classic, gooey toasted coconut and pecan topping.
$15.25 (8 in. square tart) A butter almond crust with a raspberry smear, and rich chocolate truffle filling – For the serious chocoholic!
Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Tart
$12.25 (9 in. round) Like a big chocolate chip cookie in a pie shell. Serve warm topped with ice-cream! Yum!
Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie
$11.95 (6 in. round)
Chocolate Mint Cake
A marvelous cake with layers of chocolate cake, mint mousse with a touch of peppermint schnapps & mint cookie crumbs– smothered in chocolate Ganache.
$25.95 (9 in. round)*
$11.95 (6 in. round)
Chocolate Raspberry Decadence Cake
A delightful cake with layers of chocolate cake & chocolate mousse, a touch of raspberry liquor - enrobed in chocolate Ganache
$25.95 (9 in. round*)
$11.75 (8 in. square tart) Our lemon crème brulee tart combines the thin yet rich texture of crème brulee with the zip of lemon meringue pie; over a shortbread crust.
Lemon Crème Brûlée Tart
$7.25 (7 in. loaf) Luscious lemon pound cake with lemon glaze.
$16.95 (9 in. round)* “Better than vacation Key Lime Pie” is made fresh with real key lime juice & lime zest with a dollop of whipped cream.
Key Lime Pie
$5.95 Our family sized Irish Soda Bread is busting with butter, buttermilk & raisins.
Irish Soda Bread
$7.95 Our family sized Easter Bread is a mildly sweet bread with golden raisins,candied orange peel, toasted almonds and almond drizzle.
$13.50 (9 in. round) Rhubarb Apple Crisp combines apples with tangy rhubarb & a delightful crunchy topping.
Rhubarb Apple Crisp
$13.95 (9 in. round) Rhubarb Custard Pie combines rich custard with the tang of rhubarb for a delicious dessert.
Rhubarb Custard Pie
$6.95 (7" loaf) Wonderful moist zucchini bread made with our homegrown zucchini.
$15.95 (7 in. round) Velvety cheesecake infused with pumpkin over a gingersnap crust.
$15.25 Classic sweet potato pie with spiced ginger crumble topping.
Sweet Potato Pie
$15.25 (9 in. round) A seasonal twist on our famous Apple Cider Donut Bread Pudding with added pumpkin, cranberries and seasonal spices.
Harvest Donut Bread Pudding
$0.75ea. $6.95 / doz. $3.75 / half doz. Old-fashioned cake donuts made with fresh apple cider. Available: plain, cinnamon sugar or white sugar
Apple Cider Donuts
$2.25ea. An assortment of fresh muffins baked daily.
$9.50 / lb. Snickerdoodle, Cranberry Oat Apricot, Chewy Coconut, Butter Pecan Shortbread, Chocolate Chip, Toll House Oat, Oatmeal Raisin, Double Chocolate Truffle, Almond Champagne, Tipsy Molasses, Amish Butter, Peanut Butter, Sugar & Spice
$6.95 / lb. A healthy choice – perfect as cereal or over yogurt. Available with raisins, cranberries or plain.
$9.50 / lb. Combines the healthy ingredients of our granola for a great on-the-go snack.
Grand Granola Bars
$9.50 / lb. Wonderful dipped in coffee or wine!
Toasted Almond Biscotti
Mini Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Tart $4.95 Mini Apple Cider Donut Bread Pudding $3.50 Mini Harvest Bread Pudding $4.25 Mini Chocolate Nut Rugelach Tart $4.95 Mini Key Lime Pie $5.95 Mini Lemon Creme Brulee Tart $3.95
$9.50 / lb.Our classic dark chocolate brownies are chewy, never “cakey!” available with or without walnuts
$5.95 Our homemade brownies with Mint Chocolate, Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Peanut Butter or Rocky Road Topping.
Fancy Brownies For 2*
$3.95ea Carrot Cake, Dark Chocolate Mousse $3.50, Luscious Lemon (Our classic lemon cake with lemon cream cheese frosting) $3.95 or Apple Cake (Our classic apple cake with the added delight of maple cream cheese frosting)$3.95
$12.95 / lb. Neighbor Marge’s special recipe – A holiday favorite made so popular that we now offer them year round!
$2.75 ea. For macaroon fans, our ice cream scoop sized macaroons are filled with moist coconut, a chocolate dipped base and a touch of orange essence. *Now available in bite sized mini macaroons! $8.50 / dozen minis
$10.25 / lb. We offer all your traditional cream & butter fudge flavors as well as seasonal favorites.
Cream & Butter Fudge
Planning a party or wedding? Stop in and check out our fudge favors!
HOME-BAKED FRUIT PIES
$15.25 (a delightful combination of apples, raspberries, blackberries, strawberries and rhubarb.)